Versions Compared

Version Old Version 8 New Version 9
Changes made by

Janina Mincer-Daszkiewicz

Janina Mincer-Daszkiewicz

Saved on

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.
Info

Levels of estimated error severity.

If an error is present in the context of an API (or endpoint), it applies only to that API (or endpoint).

Status
colourRed
titleCritical

This severity level implies that the process always/usually works badly.

Status
colourYellow
titleMAJOR

This severity level implies that the process works badly in some cases.

Status
colourPurple
titleMEDIUM

This flaw results in unfavorable behavior but the system remains functioning.

Status
colourBlue
titleLOW

This type of flaw won’t cause any major breakdown in the system.

Panel
panelIconId203c
panelIcon:bangbang:
panelIconText‼️
bgColor#FFEBE6

List of identified issues in this category (click on the title to show details)

Expand
titleGEN-001: Allowing users to enter incorrect data

Description

If a specification requires some field to be in a specific format, applications should have proper server-side validation to prevent their users from entering incorrect data. Perfect examples are fields where the value is expected to be an email or a URL.

Estimated severity

Status
colourYellow
titleMAJOR

Examples

 

Suggested action

Enforceabsolutecompliance with the specification

How communicated

Monitoring system

Problem occurred for at least 15 providers in PROD (link1, link2)

Expand
titleGEN-002: Missing required fields

Description

Fields specified as required must be provided in the API response. Such errors in many cases can be easily detected in your tests by validating your responses with the XSD schemas. You can also use validators available in the DEV Registry Service.

Estimated severity

Status
colourRed
titleCritical

Examples

 

Suggested action

Enforceabsolutecompliance with the specification

How communicated

Monitoring system

Problem occurred for at least 11 providers in PROD

Expand
titleGEN-003: Attaching request body in error-response

Description

A provider attaches full request body and parameters in error-responses in the Stats Portal

Estimated severity

Status
colourPurple
titleMEDIUM

Examples

 

Suggested action

A provider should stop doing this, because it might result in leaking private data when such errors are reported to the Stats Portal

How communicated

Monitoring system

Problem occurred for at least 2 providers in PROD (link1, link2) and 1 other in DEV

Expand
titleGEN-004: Attaching stack trace in error-response

Description

Full stack traces aren't helpful to other partners and are only making reports in the Stats Portal less readable.

Estimated severity

Status
colourBlue
titleLOW

Examples

 

Suggested action

In case of unknown errors it is enough to return some generic message, e.g. "Something went wrong. Administrators have been notified. We'll try to fix it ASAP.", as suggested in the specification.

How communicated

Monitoring system

Problem occurred for at least 2 providers in PROD (link1, link2).

Expand
titleGEN-005: Wrong answer to a CNR or GET as part of CNR

Description

According to specification “Once you receive a change notification, you respond with HTTP 200, and add the received identifiers to a queue. Later on, in the background, you will attempt to update your locally stored information on the received entities (e.g. by calling the get endpoints of the APIs which describe this entity).

You SHOULD NOT try to refresh your data before sending your CNR API response. Refreshing the data (e.g. calling the get endpoint) is a separate operation, and the result of this operation MUST NOT influence the HTTP response of your CNR API”

A number of partner send some error codes instead.

Estimated severity

Status
colourYellow
titleMAJOR

Examples

 

Suggested action

Enforceabsolutecompliance with the specification

How communicated

Email correspondence with providers, testing sessions, GitHub

This error was encountered in a number of mobility systems